deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

Featured in Groups:

Details

April 7, 2012
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 4
Favourites: 1 [who?]

Views: 2,472 (0 today)
[x]
I'm a big fan of Tolkien's work and fantasy in general, as can be seen from my ever-growing album of fanart for Lord of the Rings. But of all Fantasy-related fiction I have a special soft spot for Sword & Sorcery in particular. One thing that bothers me with much of existing fanart for Tolkien is how most people aren't doing their own thing with the material at all and just seem to copy the designs from the films. Either that, or then they make anime-inspired bishonen-versions of the characters, which is fine but tends to make everybody look identical. In the worst cases the fanart is nothing but pencil-tracing of promotional photos from the films, which I think is very inhibiting for artistic growth. I know this makes me sound like an elitist, but I'd prefer to see people make a visibly bigger effort.

Because of this I decided that I would try to make designs in my own fanart different from the movies as much as possible, to not just copy everything. As I mentioned earlier, I like Sword & Sorcery a lot, so I came up with the idea of taking inspiration from Frazetta and other artists who've popularized the aesthetics of the genre. I am not comparing myself to Frazetta at all, because my art style is more cartoony and amateurish compared to his. But the general look of badass larger-than-life fighters, who battle hordes of savage enemies and monsters to rescue damsels-in-distress, is appealing to me and I'm curious about how it works when applied to Middle-Earth. How far can the aesthetics of Conan the Barbarian etc. be applied to Tolkien's work, while still being recognizable as such? What do you think?
Add a Comment:
 
love 0 0 joy 1 1 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconfergusthefiddler:
To me, Tolkien work is a lot more likely to be depicted in a sober way, a la Alan Lee, without exagerations like WOW and all that bastardised rubish so popular nowadays; I hate too manga Tolkien's character depictions - argh! - or even slash - sorry, but I think that mr. Tolkien wouldn't be very pleased with that stuff -.Funnily, I found that the less muscle the hero, the more heroic is the fact. :D
So, when I want to depict some Tolkien scene, I try to use an european cartoony style - like my Hobbit's sketches - or look for some real medieval references. For this, I think Harold Foster's work is unbeatable.
For the Silmarillion, I'm planning to do something with a medieval illuminated manuscript flavour, in a X - XI century english - french style.
And of course, the films vision is only PJ's depiction of LOTR. Luckily, Tolkien descriptions are both accurate & vague enough at the same time for to allow anyone to buil his/her own rendering of Middle Earth.;)

All the best,

Fer
Reply
:iconmara999:
~Mara999 Apr 29, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Agreed, I think a Franco-Belgian style would work well for Tolkien's work. One artist I would really want to see make a graphic novel adaption of pretty much any story set in Middle Earth is Peter Madsen, the man behind the Danish comic Valhalla, which mixes the best parts of the Franco-Belgian style an[link] Nordic fairytale elements.
Reply
:iconfergusthefiddler:
Beatiful style, indeed. Really good for a more 'childish' tale like the hobbit is but for a more, say,'serious' style; what do you think about this guy? I really love his treatment of colour:

[link]

[link]
Reply
:iconmara999:
Mood: Joy ~Mara999 Apr 29, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Hmm, tough decision. The colours are a bit more muted than I would prefer, but it fits with his style. At first I wasn't sure what to think of the Roman-style dwarves, but I'm warming up to them and they're definitely unique compared to the usual way of mixing Vikings with Scots. My favourite part would be the orcs, because they remind me of the ape-monsters of Frank Frazetta. Yeah, I could see this working well for either a graphic novel or an illustrated copy.
Reply
Add a Comment: